Java 3 block hits are reach

[Snodia]

No, in a straightline situation I want awareness of the fact that if anyone gets a 3 block hit they are cheating. Unless there is a loss of packets the ping of the player doesn't matter.

Then I would still like to know why this is in the "suggestions" section if it is not a suggestion.

 

[OnePointEight.exe]

Then I would still like to know why this is in the "suggestions" section if it is not a suggestion.

Fine fine fine... I posted it here because basically anywhere else no one would notice... Sorry...

 

[Shallidor]

This is how ticks work. There are 20 tps which is how often information is monitored.

View attachment 146813

They can't make it longer if that's what you are asking.

Because when a player sends an attack packet they move 0.6 times as fast as usual.

That would support my cause even greater and make the hits even shorter.

Thanks, this clarifies it a lot!
I honestly never knew attacks slow the player down.
About the speed, I meant that it feels like speed increases your reach, so you can reach 3 blocks without cheat with 1 ms.

 

[OnePointEight.exe]

Thanks, this clarifies it a lot!
I honestly never knew attacks slow the player down.
About the speed, I meant that it feels like speed increases your reach, so you can reach 3 blocks without cheat with 1 ms.

Speed does not change reach however what it can do is make it so if you S tap or walk away from the player you move further getting longer hits.

 

[Shallidor]

Speed does not change reach however what it can do is make it so if you S tap or walk away from the player you move further getting longer hits.

Ah because the hit package has to wait for the next game tick, so you walk away before before the hit becomes visible, right?

 

[OnePointEight.exe]

Ah because the hit package has to wait for the next game tick, so you walk away before before the hit becomes visible, right?

I honestly have next to no clue on how this precisely works. Because even if you move before the hit registers the server should see you in the place where you were when you hit them. So on your side, yes the hit should look further away. However on server side that shouldn't change. I have no idea how reach hits happen when people lag. What I do know is that however they work having speed let's you get larger laggy reach hits since you can move faster and away from them.

 

[Lilleh__]

Because that's blocks you can mine. Not hitting a player.

Even in Minecraft which has unrealistic stuff like entire islands being able to float, that logic seems broken.

 

[Lilleh__]

it feels like speed increases your reach,

That's bc it increases your FOV.

 

[OnePointEight.exe]

Even in Minecraft which has unrealistic stuff like entire islands being able to float, that logic seems broken.

PVP is the only place reach is 3 blocks you're right it's wierd. Even fighting mobs is 5 blocks.

 

[Lilleh__]

PVP is the only place reach is 3 blocks you're right it's wierd. Even fighting mobs is 5 blocks.

Have Mojang said that its intentional or are they even aware of it?

 

[OnePointEight.exe]

Have Mojang said that its intentional or are they even aware of it?

I mean it's in the game code, they must be aware of it.