Minecraft PC IP: play.cubecraft.net

Should this be added? (I don't see a reason why not)

  • Yes! Both the function and the listed resources taken!

    Votes: 16 59.3%
  • Yes! But only the function!

    Votes: 6 22.2%
  • Yes! But only the items taken when upgrading a generator the normal way!

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No! None of these should be added! (State "why?" in the comments!)

    Votes: 5 18.5%

  • Total voters
    27
Status
Not open for further replies.

Gainfullterror

Forum Professional
Mar 24, 2016
5,040
10,898
624
22
Breakfast for Dinner Club HQ
www.cubecraft.net
Say you're in a hurry, dudes at your base, and you need that quick iron boost. It'll be easier to do, but not OP. If it costs the same to do both, no one would ever do it the slow way, the way it's supposed to be done. I don't personally agree with this idea, but I'm trying to find a way that it could still work.
So in that case, the tower defense mechanic should be removed.


I don't know.. I feel as if it would cause a lot of confusion, I mean it doesn't take long to upgrade a gen anyways. Unless both ways still work and it's just an added feature, It would be cool if that was the case :)

And tower defense? People use it all the time. It's just to save a few seconds of time that could be vital
 

Wouze

Well-Known Member
Apr 9, 2016
377
136
123
23
New york
So in that case, the tower defense mechanic should be removed.
Not at all, tower defense is a completely different game than eggwars. In tower defense it's simply to make it easier, there is no PVP aspect that could make it unbalanced. Don't be so salty i don't COMPLETELY agree with you.
 

Gainfullterror

Forum Professional
Mar 24, 2016
5,040
10,898
624
22
Breakfast for Dinner Club HQ
www.cubecraft.net
Not at all, tower defense is a completely different game than eggwars. In tower defense it's simply to make it easier, there is no PVP aspect that could make it unbalanced. Don't be so salty i don't COMPLETELY agree with you.
In tower defense, if you do it just a little too late, the mobs could get through and finish you off after Armageddon.
And why do you assume I'm salty? I formulate sentences like this all the time.
 

Wouze

Well-Known Member
Apr 9, 2016
377
136
123
23
New york
In tower defense, if you do it just a little too late, the mobs could get through and finish you off after Armageddon.
And why do you assume I'm salty? I formulate sentences like this all the time.
Mobs are very different from PVP, It's just not the same thing. I assume you're salty because you certainly sound it. I'm just trying to find a way that this suggestion could work in favor of everyone. Lets not get off topic.
 

Earth

Forum Veteran
Oct 21, 2015
1,335
5,759
408
23
Nowhere
to all of you people saying it'll be too OP or stuff like that

wow you're gonna save a whoooole 1-2 SECONDS of gameplay too OP -472 jesus christ remove this suggestion this is way too OP omg

I seriously have no idea HOW this could EVER be too overpowered
i agree with this suggestion as i am a really lazy person tyvm
 

Gainfullterror

Forum Professional
Mar 24, 2016
5,040
10,898
624
22
Breakfast for Dinner Club HQ
www.cubecraft.net
I'm just trying to find a way that this suggestion could work in favor of everyone. Lets not get off topic.
Tower defense is an element of the topic, look at the thread.
The sneak right click is just to save a bit of time, 2 seconds max. How is that overpowered? Upgrading a generator in the middle of a fight won't let you win.
I don't know how my text looks salty, but ok
 

Wouze

Well-Known Member
Apr 9, 2016
377
136
123
23
New york
Tower defense is an element of the topic, look at the thread.
The sneak right click is just to save a bit of time, 2 seconds max. How is that overpowered? Upgrading a generator in the middle of a fight won't let you win.
I don't know how my text looks salty, but ok
Really? Because the thread title is "Eggwars generators suggestion."
 

Wouze

Well-Known Member
Apr 9, 2016
377
136
123
23
New york
Eggwars gets the addition.
The addition is based off of tower defense.
The title is not everything.

Arguing further about this would make the thread messy, so leave it at that.
Tower defense and Eggwars are 2 completely different games. I'll leave it at that.
 

Dreym

Well-Known Member
Oct 9, 2016
141
95
108
United Kingdom
I agree completely with Wouze. There is no reason this should be implemented, the fact that you are solely comparing this to a completely different mini-game further illustrates your unjustified reasoning for adding such a feature. If it ain't broken don't fix it, but if it works....
Upgrade it normally :P
 

Gainfullterror

Forum Professional
Mar 24, 2016
5,040
10,898
624
22
Breakfast for Dinner Club HQ
www.cubecraft.net
I agree completely with Wouze. There is no reason this should be implemented, the fact that you are solely comparing this to a completely different mini-game further illustrates your unjustified reasoning for adding such a feature. If it ain't broken don't fix it, but if it works....
Upgrade it normally :p
Have you read what I said?
It's to save a few seconds of time and to make the game feel swift when in a hurry.
This isn't overpowered nor underpowered.
 

Gainfullterror

Forum Professional
Mar 24, 2016
5,040
10,898
624
22
Breakfast for Dinner Club HQ
www.cubecraft.net
It is unnessecary and pointless.
3e1.png
 

iGamingMango

Well-Known Member
Oct 21, 2016
218
90
103
The basement
this is probably going to be an absolutely useless comment but maybye it could do a shift-right click as an actual generator upgrade or just be in op mode?
 

Gainfullterror

Forum Professional
Mar 24, 2016
5,040
10,898
624
22
Breakfast for Dinner Club HQ
www.cubecraft.net
this is probably going to be an absolutely useless comment but maybye it could do a shift-right click as an actual generator upgrade or just be in op mode?
My suggestion is as follows:
You sneak-rightclick a generator to upgrade it to the next tier provided you have the correct resources.
And an optional feature would be listing the resources spent on that upgraded generator in your chat log.
This would count for all gamemodes
 

Lezappen

Forum Expert
Jan 30, 2016
2,174
3,886
338
Toulouse (France)
The suggestion: shift - right clicking generators to upgrade them.

I like this idea as it's intuitive to learn and doesn't force you to go through the generator's user interface which is tedious on a long term basis and becomes repetitive and is one of those little things that make you lose a bit of what we feel like unnecessary time.

People argue that its an important part of gameplay that you shouldn't be able to quickly upgrade as it forces you to pay attention to your surroundings.

Personally I don't see how this would significantly change the game apart from making the game more fluid and intuitive.
Upgrading takes less than 3 seconds and I don't upgrade the generators during pvp as I'm usually using them to refresh my armor or buy food if I am to use them at that time.

Other people argue that it already doesn't take long and is fine as it is, but as it is currently you have to right click the sign, left click the upgrade button and the menu closes and your gen is upgraded, for multiple upgrades doing this repetitivly gets annoying on the long run and I fully understand gainfullterror's point of view who has been playing for a long time.

Man some people on this thread are stupid....
As much as people may be incoherent at times, please refrain from causing any unnecessary drama and understand that some people may have different points of views that at times are very different to yours.
Insulting them doesn't amount to anything positive.

Changed it for you Lezappen.. happy?
No need to be insolent about it, I didn't ask you to change your comment. The reason I warned you on that post wasn't because it made me unhappy, and you stating that you changed it just for me, highlights the disregard you have for the other people. Please pm me if you wish to further discuss this matter.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Gainfullterror
Status
Not open for further replies.
Members Online

Team online

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

JokeKaedee wrote on WorriedSkate940's profile.
Happy birthday, Skate! 🛼 🎈
As I am pretty close to fact #60, I would like to ask something. Do you all like Minecraft facts or irl facts? I have been posting Minecraft facts for five days for a change. If you want mc facts, I am pretty sure I have a few more. If you all want irl facts, I have no problem in doing that! Although I would have to check the availability of the facts, this would help me post more interesting and fun facts!
Reesle wrote on MCotoulas's profile.
Happy Birthday! 🎂
Reesle wrote on adrian525pl's profile.
Happy Birthday! 🎉✨
Reesle wrote on WorriedSkate940's profile.
Happy Birthday! 🥳
Top Bottom