Discussion in 'Minecraft Creations' started by Kris_J, Jul 29, 2016.
I like it, but I would add more detail and low the mountains and make them bigger.
I don't really think it needs more detail in my opinion, because I don't like over-detailing :/, thanks though!
Them do not ask for opinions.
Hangar is completely right. Don't ask forum members what you can do better or what they would like to see, if you aren't going to listen to them. Detail is a huge importance for any build. I think it needs more detail too, the mountains do need more detail. I do like the village part though.
See? I am not alone
'like it' doesn't mean opinion. You can just say if you like it or not . I do like it
Well, it's a complex situation. I like it, but I suggest things to make me like more.
Ok, but if someone does not completely like it, they are going to say why they don't completely like it. If someone said they didn't like a your build, you would want to know why.
I said thanks, I don't see why you guys need to start a problem, I simply said "Like it?" not "Hey guys what should I do to improve this" I find it annoying that you need to cause this even though when he said "It needs more detail" but I won't take that advice because in MY opinion I don't need to, I do care about what people think but not as much as I do. If someone brings up a problem and I agree with that, I will try to fix it. So no offence, but I really don't want you here. Bye!
I like the main building, I don't like the mountain because it lacks a lot of volume and just look like sticks -
I don't know how the village huts look like as it's a little further away.
If someone doesn't like something, they state why so you can adjust it.
I cooked a meal and the judge comes over, tasted it and said "I don't like it"
You're going to wonder what it is that he doesn't like. You want to know so you can improve it better but if he doesn't say, you won't know.
It's not like he said it to make you feel bad or anything, he did it with good intention. I think your build (if it is your build) can be improved drastically if you put in more effort into the mountain details like how you did with the main castle/village thing.
Edit: Maybe you should edit your OP in a way people understand better. If you do not want opinions then state it there cause we just thought you would like some.
Something like "Do you like this or dislike it? I do not need opinions on how to improve it but thank you"
If you made something you are proud of, but some people don't like it, although you do. Don't change it. The mountains are not supposed to be completely natural, they are made to look like a defense for the village/kingdom. Also, from what I said earlier, I'm proud of it (all of it), so I'm not changing it, I simply wanted people to say "I like it" or "I don't like it" and that's completely fine if you don't like it, but to say I need to change something that I'm already proud of won't help. EDIT: Also, when you say "I don't like it" I don't feel bad, and also you are bringing up something irrelevant to the situation. I never even wanted to start any drama, but that is all people do these days.
Thank you for your opinion.
Didn't say you needed to change it. We said that the mountain detail is not the best, and that adding in more detail would make it look better. Never did we say you had to change it. If you like it and you don't want other's opinions.. Why would you post it to the forums in the first place?
I wanted to give people inspiration.
Wouldn't refer to the mountains with a lack of detail. If I were you I'd edit the mountains though, your mountains are too sharp, try to shape them like realistic mountains. Oh yeah, you should also use a different block palette for your mountains as mountains don't often consist out of bricks and cobblestone. Also, your castle is good, but the tower's roofs are too big, so I'd edit that too. Overall it's a good build, but it needs some improvement.
Read what I said about the mountains. Thank you anyways EDIT: Normal & Realistic mountains are overused in my opinion, and I think these look more interesting and better (MY OPINION)
I understand where you're coming from. I just wanted to point out that they wrote their opinion with good intentions and thought they would include what they didn't like.
I do like your castle area. If it's for defense related then it should be fine. You don't have to change it. You never said anything about how they were supposed to look like so we thought you would like some opinion on improving it.
Your OP provided little detail, just "Like it?" maybe try explaining your structure so we can understand it better.
We're not looking for drama, don't worry.
Someone doesn't always agree with someone else's opinion, I can ask for critisism, but when I get critism I absolutely don't agree with, I won't use it.