Reports Suggestion

[xXNiChO_29Xx]

Okay, I have a quite simple and direct suggestion for the reports.

My Suggestion is that all Hacker videos should not have been edited, not music no nothing.

Why?

It can confuse people, it can lead to false ban. The audio is really important, the hits everything...

I have seen a lot of videos with music and no Minecraft audio...

I hate how people get false banned by someone that wants to ban him because hates him or something and then edit the video, delete video sound and add music!

Unfair.

 

[agent320]

Ehhhhmm
First: There is no way to prove a video wasnt edited except the aufia is completly taken away or sth similar
second: The audia doesnt matter 1 single thing

 

[CR7Joyce]

Okay, I have a quite simple and direct suggestion for the reports.

My Suggestion is that all Hacker videos should not have been edited, not music no nothing.

Why?

It can confuse people, it can lead to false ban. The audio is really important, the hits everything...

I have seen a lot of videos with music and no Minecraft audio...

I hate how people get false banned by someone that wants to ban him because hates him or something and then edit the video, delete video sound and add music!

Unfair.

I have quite a nice amount of accepted reports and I never use minecraft sound or any audio at all. If you use a texture pack which makes it clear when someone gets hit, you don't even need sound in my opinion.

 

[Ghoste]

Okay, I have a quite simple and direct suggestion for the reports.

My Suggestion is that all Hacker videos should not have been edited, not music no nothing.

Why?

It can confuse people, it can lead to false ban. The audio is really important, the hits everything...

I have seen a lot of videos with music and no Minecraft audio...

I hate how people get false banned by someone that wants to ban him because hates him or something and then edit the video, delete video sound and add music!

Unfair.

I record hackers without sound, and they are still given the punishment they deserve.
So it seems to be unnecessary for this.

Sorry.

 

[zDutchie]

All up to the reporter :)

Sometimes edits make it easier for us staff to see what's going on. I personally don't think we should limit users in how they should report.

 

[Troublesomee]

I don't think it's necessary because the it's up to the reporter, he could edit the video in each way he wants to, if it's just clear that the player is hacking there is no need to put the sounds over it, It could make it easier in 1.8, why? Because most of the times, in 1.8 a hackers sets his fighting speed at max, than, it could be pretty handy if you can hear the sounds, it would sounds like atatattatatatatatatat. :)

 

[Deleted member 204478]

Some of my reports don't even have sound.
Editing can actually make it easier for the staff to expose the player and punish them.
For example, the reporter can use a slow-mo effect to make it clearer.

 

[HackersDontWin]

Okay, I have a quite simple and direct suggestion for the reports.

My Suggestion is that all Hacker videos should not have been edited, not music no nothing.

Why?

It can confuse people, it can lead to false ban. The audio is really important, the hits everything...

I have seen a lot of videos with music and no Minecraft audio...

I hate how people get false banned by someone that wants to ban him because hates him or something and then edit the video, delete video sound and add music!

Unfair.

Edited videos can help like zDutchie said above, but if this were to be implemented, then what about the players who has minecraft sounds off all the time? I know that it can be frustrating to be false banned, but that's why there is an option to appeal. If you explain in the appeal that the video is edited and how, I'm sure that you'll get unbanned and the person who edited the video would be punished with the same punishment that you initially got :)

Taken from the official rules thread:

 

[Darkform9]

I think it wouldn't really work, I don't use sound at all while playing and if it was a requirement it would serious take a long time to set it up and still have time to catch the hacker in the act.

 

[Younisco]

We don't need audio for most cases as they may not even need audio. For example, fly hackers, safewalkers, BHoppers ect, don't need audio. However for PvP hacks such as killaura or critical hits, audio is preferable to make the job easier for us. :D

 

[xXNiChO_29Xx]

We don't need audio for most cases as they may not even need audio. For example, fly hackers, safewalkers, BHoppers ect, don't need audio. However for PvP hacks such as killaura or critical hits, audio is preferable to make the job easier for us. :D

This is what I mean but everyone is against me...

 

[Refresco]

Edited videos can help like zDutchie said above, but if this were to be implemented, then what about the players who has minecraft sounds off all the time? I know that it can be frustrating to be false banned, but that's why there is an option to appeal. If you explain in the appeal that the video is edited and how, I'm sure that you'll get unbanned and the person who edited the video would be punished with the same punishment that you initially got :)

Taken from the official rules thread:
View attachment 131548

zDutchie is gone it is DutchieTheKid :P

 

[HackersDontWin]

zDutchie is gone it is DutchieTheKid :p

Just used to typing zDutchie :P