Bedrock Eating whilst being attacked.

[Conea64]

Before I begin, this post was written very angrily after sweating at solo skywars for 30minuets so it may be unreasonable

Now that I read this, it is unreasonable .

Imagine this:
Your in a fight, you are about to win the other person is on 3 hearts give or take, they have full prot one iron armour and you are slaying them.
They start eating a golden apple.
There hearts race up to full and stay that way for another '3' seconds you are now on two hearts without a gapple, so you have to attempt to fight but die.

What I propose is something that minecraft said they are going to release already (this is experimental)(but cube is a bit behind on the latest updates so meh)is that if you take any damage whilst eating then the eating will cancel. Seems simple.

It's not even like there is no other way of surviving a fight that you are loosing, you can always run.

Ok done

 

[Gregeyy]

EDIT: I agree with @_The13thDoctor_'s comment.
Have a nice day and don't be angry!

 

[_The13thDoctor_]

Oh, heck to the no. Not being able to eat while fighting was one of the worst features added in the new "combat update" which already triggers me lol. Tryhards and or people who are really good would dominate but also cleaning would be even worse. I don't think many people could play anymore if this is added. Players who are on a lower skill level or on a device that is not as good would really suffer as now they don't have much of anything to save themselves. Take this from someone who is able to chain a hit and continue doing so while running around the user like a merry-go-round. I already feel bad about doing that so not being able to regen especially when in a 2v1 would be torture. I think you would be even angrier having this happen then what's going on now.

TL;DR: Pls no.

 

[Gregeyy]

Oh, heck to the no. Not being able to eat while fighting was one of the worst features added in the new "combat update" which already triggers me lol. Tryhards and or people who are really good would dominate but also cleaning would be even worse. I don't think many people could play anymore if this is added. Players who are on a lower skill level or on a device that is not as good would really suffer as now they don't have much of anything to save themselves. Take this from someone who is able to chain a hit and continue doing so while running around the user like a merry-go-round. I already feel bad about doing that so not being able to regen especially when in a 2v1 would be torture. I think you would be even angrier having this happen then what's going on now.

TL;DR: Pls no.

You're also right
I've changed the comment!

 

[_The13thDoctor_]

You're also right
Should I change my comment?

Possibly.

The main issue is the new combat essentially normalizes combat but since most updates are focused on content for regular Minecraft they typically ignore how it effects servers like Cube with their combat system. Hate it or love it 1.8 and 1.9 are so much better. This new combat closes the skill gap, nerfs bows, adds ridiculous knockback, and other things. I just really don't like. I really am hoping Cube doesn't update to the new combat.

 

[FnigePython]

Oh, heck to the no. Not being able to eat while fighting was one of the worst features added in the new "combat update" which already triggers me lol. Tryhards and or people who are really good would dominate but also cleaning would be even worse. I don't think many people could play anymore if this is added. Players who are on a lower skill level or on a device that is not as good would really suffer as now they don't have much of anything to save themselves. Take this from someone who is able to chain a hit and continue doing so while running around the user like a merry-go-round. I already feel bad about doing that so not being able to regen especially when in a 2v1 would be torture. I think you would be even angrier having this happen then what's going on now.

TL;DR: Pls no.

add on the fact that the new system is only in the experimental phase

 

[Gregeyy]

Possibly.

The main issue is the new combat essentially normalizes combat but since most updates are focused on content for regular Minecraft they typically ignore how it effects servers like Cube with their combat system. Hate it or love it 1.8 and 1.9 are so much better. This new combat closes the skill gap, nerfs bows, adds ridiculous knockback, and other things. I just really don't like. I really am hoping Cube doesn't update to the new combat.

Thanks for the explanation! I've changed my comment. The reason I thought it could be a good adition is that I don't know Bedrock's pvp mechanics. Have a nice day!

@Conea64 I advise you to add a poll so people can express their opinion easily

 

[_The13thDoctor_]

add on the fact that the new system is only in the experimental phase

Which sadly they seem really eager to add. Despite most people not liking it.

 

[Eli]

It's a really nice feature that'll be coming with the experimental update. Since fights currently get carried out for so long because of food and golden apples but... I would wait for the experimental combat to be released, since those snapshots are being revised by Mojang directly and a greater part of the MineCraft community, which should ensure the majority is okay with the change. Don't think we should be getting ahead of Minecraft itself and implement things that may not really work that well.

 

[Conea64]

Thanks for the explanation! I've changed my comment. The reason I thought it could be a good adition is that I don't know Bedrock's pvp mechanics. Have a nice day!

@Conea64 I advise you to add a poll so people can express their opinion easily

Added the poll

 

[ReMD0G]

Very unnecessary but still could be added to make the game more sense

 

[ReMD0G]

Yes, I believe that some one told you to do it.

 

[_The13thDoctor_]

Very unnecessary but still could be added to make the game more sense

Minecraft is the last game that needs to make sense. xD

 

[Technosword]

Oh, heck to the no. Not being able to eat while fighting was one of the worst features added in the new "combat update" which already triggers me lol. Tryhards and or people who are really good would dominate but also cleaning would be even worse. I don't think many people could play anymore if this is added. Players who are on a lower skill level or on a device that is not as good would really suffer as now they don't have much of anything to save themselves. Take this from someone who is able to chain a hit and continue doing so while running around the user like a merry-go-round. I already feel bad about doing that so not being able to regen especially when in a 2v1 would be torture. I think you would be even angrier having this happen then what's going on now.

TL;DR: Pls no.

^ completely agree sorry

 

[_The13thDoctor_]

^ completely agree sorry

Honestly if I had the time I could go into a full essay about the issues with the combat changes will have on servers and how silly it is.

 

[Queen Ualala]

If someone eats while they are being hit, please step away. It is impolite to bother someone while they are eating.

 

[FnigePython]

Possibly.

The main issue is the new combat essentially normalizes combat but since most updates are focused on content for regular Minecraft they typically ignore how it effects servers like Cube with their combat system. Hate it or love it 1.8 and 1.9 are so much better. This new combat closes the skill gap, nerfs bows, adds ridiculous knockback, and other things. I just really don't like. I really am hoping Cube doesn't update to the new combat.

Also i should point out that Jebby is listening to people, why dont you suggest that

 

[FnigePython]

Which sadly they seem really eager to add. Despite most people not liking it.

Eh, I dont know where your looking at but it seems to be positive where i am looking at.

 

[Barriss]

Before I begin, this post was written very angrily after sweating at solo skywars for 30minuets so it may be unreasonable

Now that I read this, it is unreasonable .

Imagine this:
Your in a fight, you are about to win the other person is on 3 hearts give or take, they have full prot one iron armour and you are slaying them.
They start eating a golden apple.
There hearts race up to full and stay that way for another '3' seconds you are now on two hearts without a gapple, so you have to attempt to fight but die.

What I propose is something that minecraft said they are going to release already (this is experimental)(but cube is a bit behind on the latest updates so meh)is that if you take any damage whilst eating then the eating will cancel. Seems simple.

It's not even like there is no other way of surviving a fight that you are loosing, you can always run.

Ok done

Not too keen on this idea myself haha! Great suggestion though, Interesting to see what others think of it. It's a no from me sorry, you aren't going through to the Finale :) xD

 

[_The13thDoctor_]

Also i should point out that Jebby is listening to people, why dont you suggest that

Listening to people but only to a certain degree. Plus I'm not sure he is too focused on the effects on servers.

Eh, I dont know where your looking at but it seems to be positive where i am looking at.

Ahh... Depends on who you talk to from where.