Web Staff applications (New settings)

Discussion in 'Suggestions' started by ImMinec, Aug 13, 2019.

  1. ImMinec

    ImMinec Member

    Messages:
    77
    Likes Received:
    82
    Trophy Points:
    19
    Currently, when you apply for a staff member, the application for you is not registered, that is, you cannot see what you applied, only when you apply does it send you a message saying "Thank you for applying, if your response has been successful we will let you know". Well, my proposal is to save all your applications in the applications section for staff, so that you can see the details you put (with the date) etc.
     
  2. Dutudy

    Dutudy Member

    Messages:
    1,245
    Likes Received:
    3,586
    Trophy Points:
    304
    Dutudy
    Obsidian
    PLUS
    You got a link after you applied?
     
  3. Elenahh

    Elenahh Member

    Messages:
    905
    Likes Received:
    3,422
    Trophy Points:
    324
    Elenahh
    Obsidian
    Personally, I also think the applications should be submitted in a sub-forum rather than a google form. Here's why:
    1. The applicants can organize the text in their answers better.
    - There is a question on the application asking about your skills. Some applicants might decide to go into details and answer multiple questions - ''What skills do I have?'', ''What about my work on the server proves I have these skills?'', ''How will these skills help me become a good staff member?''. If they do, they might find it difficult to organize their text on a google form, since they cannot use any kind of text formatting (use spoilers, bold, italic, change font size, etc). They can only use different paragraphs.

    2. The Helper recruitment team would be able to easily give feedback to good applicants, instead of having to create conversations in order to do it.
    - Don't get me wrong, thinking about where you have gone wrong and re-evaluating yourself is an important thing, and that part of the application process should definitely remain being a thing. BUT, I strongly support giving feedback to those applicants who meet the minimum requirements (some of them meet these requirements multiple times), have been applying for a long time and have obviously been trying to improve their work. Just like the staff team needs suggestions from members to improve their games, that's how your applicants may also run out of ideas at some point. and would like to hear some advice from other people. Now, what exactly is good about giving feedback to applicants?
    • It shows respect and appreciation to the work of the applicant.
    • It motivates the applicant to continue working and improving. It motivates them to not give up. Because, let's be real for a second - If your application gets denied over 10 times, you've spent tons of hours writing your application, thinking about where you might have gone wrong, tons of hours interacting with the community, creating quality messages/threads, creating reports, and then you don't even receive the shortest message as an answer to your application, how would you feel? What would you think? It's true that Helper is just a rank, and you do not need it to be a true Helper of the community, but it is a rank that gives you many opportunities. Opportunities to do even more for the server and the community. More than you can do as a normal member. That being said, if you are an applicant that truly loves the community and are passionate about the server, you would definitely think for yourself: ''Is there any point to continue trying? They obviously do not want me, I tried over 10 times. They showed me that after everything I have done and do, I do not deserve an opportunity.'' It is true that you probably won't give up on applying and doing good for the community even though you feel this way, but do you deserve to feel this way? Don't think so.
    • It will show the Helper recruitment team how the applicant is able to handle feedback. Will the applicant accept the criticism and work on improving using the feedback that has been given to them? That is also important because as a staff member, one of your duties is to look through suggestions, receive and give feedback.
    3. You will know who has submitted the application and when they have submitted it. That means no more fake, troll applications or if someone decides to submit loads of useless responses to the form, they would not be able to do that, because you will be able to see who is spamming applications and punish the forum user. Currently, literally everyone can access the application form, even if they do not have a forums account. What's the point in wasting time to review these applications?

    4. You should be able to make it so only forum members that meet a certain Helper requirement would be able to access the sub-forum for submitting applications. That means no more applications from people who do not meet most, if not all of the minimum requirements. That's saving up a lot of time. Time that you can use to give feedback to good applicants instead.
     
    heroBravo, Ewty, Kloska and 14 others like this.
  4. Riley

    Riley Member

    Messages:
    3,170
    Likes Received:
    8,025
    Trophy Points:
    559
    Priley
    Obsidian
    PLUS
    This is something the recruitment team needs to see. I'll go ahead and tag some people that I'm sure are involved: @Capitan @AnimalTamer1 @Younisco @zRinne

    It can't be that much work to make a new sub-forum for applications. Something that does seem like a challenge to me is filtering out those who do not meet the minimum requirements, though the same goes for the current google form and it must take way longer to click the profile link for each google form and check it that way. Regardless, I've heard of multiple cases were 'applicants' were contacted despite the fact they didn't apply, in other words: if the sub-forum would be in place, people can't just go around and apply in the name of others. Seems like another important issue to address

    TL;DR: Make a new sub-forum as Elenah said, it'll be more organized and easier to filter out insufficient candidates
     
  5. Keanu

    Keanu Member

    Messages:
    1,334
    Likes Received:
    3,449
    Trophy Points:
    304
    Keanutjuhh
    Obsidian
    PLUS
    not at all, I’ve worked with XenForo before. small thing: they should buy an applications add-on, but this is just 25 gbp.